Fooled Into Bed With My Sister:>Ep6
I did feel a spark of attraction as I held on to her though, a feeling that I desperately tried to ignore.
I released her, and stood up to leave.
“Sam?” Anna asked, stopping me.
“Yeah?” I turned around to face her. She was picking at her nails, an uncertain look on her face.
“Was I… was it good? T-The kissing, I mean,” she quickly added, face turning scarlet.
That certainly caught me off guard.
“Good? Why would you ask that?” I wondered, not sure why she would bring that up again. It clearly made her embarrassed.
“It’s just… I wanted to know how I compare to other girls. If I’m any good,” she said in a low voice. “Sorry. Forget it. I shouldn’t have asked.”
I considered leaving, but she really did look as if she wanted the answer. Was she that uncertain of herself?
“No, it’s okay. It was…” I tried to think of the right way to describe it. Amazing, sexy and fucking hot all seemed terribly inappropriate, however. “… good. It was good.”
“Really?” she asked, looking up at me with pleading blue eyes that were begging for confirmation.
“Yes. You were pretty great at it, to be honest,” I admitted.
Her face turned an even deeper shade of red, but she smiled. It was good to see her happy.
“Thanks. I just wanted to know.”
“No problem,” I said, leaving her to her thoughts.
Everything didn’t quite get back to normal. Things were still awkward between us, but they were better. A day later we decided it was time to patch things up with Melissa. The coming Friday, when her parents would be away again, we decided to meet up and watch a movie at her house.
Part of me wondered if her words had all been part of the prank, or if Melissa had meant some of the things she said.
Part of me wished she’d never interrupted my sister and me.
Part of me hated myself for feeling that way.
**
We left for Melissa’s late in the evening. We had already picked out a movie to watch and Melissa had popcorn ready for us. I suppose we all figured it was a good way to avoid talking too much.
We parked on their driveway and walked up to the front door. Melissa opened it before I could knock.
“Hi guys,” she said, making an obvious effort to act normally.
She wore a bulky gray sweater, which was unusual for her. It still didn’t succeed in hiding her impressive bosom.
“Hey,” Anna replied.
“Hey,” I echoed. “You, uh, doing well?”Content bel0ngs to Nôvel(D)r/a/ma.Org.
“Yeah. Fine,” she answered.
We made some small talk before moving to the living room. I sat down in the couch and Anna took one of the armchairs.
The tension between us was palpable. For the whole duration of the movie, no one spoke. It was a comedy, which helped to relieve some the tension. By the end of the movie, we were talking like we normally did, discussing the plot and characters, which were both subpar.
“So… we’re fine?” Melissa asked suddenly, voice pleading and unsure.
No one said anything for a while. Anna sat with her hands on her knees, looking at the floor.
“Um, well…” I said, coughing to clear my throat. “That was a bit too much for an April Fools prank.”
I turned to face Melissa, who looked intensely ashamed.
“I-I didn’t mean for that to happened…” she said defensively. “I was just trying to get you guys back for last year.”
“Well, you certainly did,” I said, half jokingly. By the look on Melissa’s face, that wasn’t helping her feel better.
“Isn’t there anything I can do?” she asked. “I’ll do anything. I just… want us to be friends again.”
“I don’t know…” I said, looking over toward Anna. She returned my helpless gaze. “It feels a bit awkward between the three of us now and I’m not sure how to fix that.”
Again, a heavy silence fell between us, no one offering any answers to the problem.
After a few awkward moments Anna took a deep breath and spoke up. “What if we embarrass you too? You know, to make us even?”
“What?” Melissa asked carefully. “How?”
“I don’t know… Take off your clothes?” she suggested.
Both Melissa and I were taken aback by my sister’s sudden suggestion.
“It’s the only way to make it even. You need to be embarrassed as well,” Anna spoke with growing conviction showing in her voice.
“I… Um, okay…” Melissa agreed. “I’ll do it.”
It was a strange idea, but I supposed my sister’s logic made sense, in an odd way.
Melissa stood up and looked like she was going to strip on the spot at first, but then seemed to hesitate.
“Do I just… do it here?” she asked.
Anna considered the question, apparently the one in charge at the moment. “No. Your room, I think. On the bed.”
Melissa seemed to accept this and left for her room without a word.
“What are you doing?” I asked Anna, after Melissa was out of sight.
“Making us even. She’s always messing with us anyway,” she explained. “If you’re okay with this?”
She waited for my answer, looking like she needed me to support her crazy idea. I sighed, nodding my head.
“Okay, fine.”
Anna nodded back to me and we walked together into Melissa’s room.
She was already down to her dark blue underwear. I wasn’t sure Anna realized how much I appreciated the situation we were in. Melissa looked beautiful.
“Here goes nothing,” she muttered, unlatching the bra.
We watched in silence as Melissa unveiled her breasts, holding her hand in front of them for a moment before taking a deep breath and displaying them freely. She bent over and slid her panties down, her breasts staying surprisingly firm as she did. The whole thing turned into something of a striptease.
“Like what you see?” she teased, looking in my direction.
I glanced in Anna’s direction, who was looking daggers at me. I wasn’t sure why she was upset. It had been her idea. To be safe, I didn’t say anything.
Melissa giggled, which didn’t seem to help Anna’s mood.
“Good,” Anna said, her voice firmly in control. “Now lay on the bed. I’ll be right back.”
She left us alone in the room for a minute or two, though it might as well have been hours. Melissa lay silently on the bed, while I stood watching, trying to adjust my pants to make my excitement less obvious.
Anna came back into the room, throwing me a silvery roll.
“Here,” she said. “Use this.”
“Uh, this is tape,” I noted.
“Yes. Silver tape. Tie her hands up.” She pointed at the metal bars at the head of the bed, holding a pair of scissors in her other hand.
“Wait, what?” Melissa said.
“We need to punish you somehow,” Anna explained, as if it was the most obvious thing in the world. “Now lay still.”
I did as she said, sitting down on one side of the bed and tying Melissa’s left hand to one of the metal bars. After I was done Anna took the tape and scissors, sitting on the other side of her naked friend.
“Sooo… what are you guys planning to do exactly?” Melissa asked, not sounding very bothered by the possibilities her situation presented.
“Not anything like that, if that’s what you’re thinking,” Anna said, finishing up on her side.
“I was thinking we might leave you like this, see what your parents think,” she explained. “Maybe leave some lotion and the dildo I know you’re hiding in here out for them to find.”
Melissa’s eyes went wide. “What?! No, wait,” she begged. “You can’t!”
“Is it really worse than what you did to us?” Anna asked.
“I’m sorry! I didn’t mean for it to go that far,” she said, a note of panic in her voice.
Anna sighed. Looking at my sister I could tell she wasn’t serious. It seemed very likely that she just wanted to scare her a little.
“Fine,” she said, dropping the bad-cop routine.
“I really am sorry,” Melissa continued. “I figured you’d notice right away. I didn’t know he would go straight to eating you out.”
“It’s fine, rea-”
“I really thought you’d notice it was a guy right away. You know I like making out a bit before the big event, right?” she rambled.